Friday, September 21, 2012

Don't you hate it when . . .

our hero doesn't call for back-up, but just goes straight in to tackle the bad guy. This happened in a novel I read in the summer (I won't name names). There was no good reason why she (yes, I am afraid it was a woman) should not have waited, but she didn't and one of her men got shot and she asks herself, 'Why did I do this, putting my deputy's life in danger?' Yes, why did you, I found myself asking, even I know why. The author feels they have to crank up the tension and put their heroine in jeopardy, but it irritates the hell out of me when a female professional behaves so, well, unprofessionally. That's the point at which I stop believing in the story. It definitely annoys me more when it's a woman behaving in this way. I felt the same another crime novel that I read on holiday, except that this time it was a middle-aged female lawyer: I found it hard to believe that someone so disorganised and even at times downright silly could ever have become a partner in a law firm. I know it was supposed to be make her seem more human, but would a man be depicted that way (I should add that the writer was a woman)? A relief then to turn to Quentin Bates's new novel, COLD COMFORT, and Sergeant Gunnhildur, who may well make mistakes, but is never downright foolish and doesn't waste time worrying about whether she's packed the right clothes. This was a good solid read and I enjoyed the Icelandic setting. I recommend it.

Labels: ,

3 Comments:

Blogger AnnOxford said...

Good to see you back blogging, Christine! Yes, I DO hate it when ... I've read so many thrillers, mysteries, in the last year where the female "detective" insinuates herself into a dangerous situation. These women seem to have no female psi sense to protect themselves, let alone sense to use assistance. One series in particular -- I could only read one-- features a graduate student at a highly regarded Ivy League campus. If she's intelligent enough to have gotten herself into this graduate school, pray tell why is she so mindless of everything around her? I do understand women writers are trying to write brave, strong women. But they can't be stupid!

Saturday, 22 September, 2012  
Blogger lyn said...

I agree! I read a crime novel a couple of months ago in which this happened & it drives me mad. It's a clumsy & unbelievable way to get to the solution of the mystery. Although at least in this book of the series the heroine didn't end up in peril of her life which she had in the previous books. The chatracter who didn't call for backup was a policewoman & should have known better. Irritating!

Sunday, 23 September, 2012  
Blogger Christine said...

Delighted to hear from you both. Clearly this struck a chord!

Monday, 24 September, 2012  

Post a Comment

Links to this post:

Create a Link

<< Home